{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"DigitalDocument","altText":"ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED ) (Motion #001) Partially Signed OTSC as to Pseudonym","alternateName":"NYSCEF-Document-000002.pdf","caption":"NYSCEF document #2 | Filed: 2026-09-16 | Filed by: COHEN, ETHAN J Filed:  Received: | Current docket status: Processed Confirmation Notice | Court: New York County Supreme Court","contentUrl":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/raw","datePublished":"2026-10-15T18:45:39+00:00","description":"NYSCEF document #2 | Filed: 2026-09-16 | Filed by: COHEN, ETHAN J Filed:  Received: | Current docket status: Processed Confirmation Notice | Court: New York County Supreme Court","encodingFormat":"application/pdf","identifier":"357","isAccessibleForFree":true,"machineReadable":{"json":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/index.json","markdown":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/index.md"},"name":"ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED ) (Motion #001) Partially Signed OTSC as to Pseudonym","ocrStatus":"ready","ocrText":"--- Page 1 ---\nAt\nof the Supreme Court of\nthe State\nof NewYork County of NewYork,\nheld\nat the Courthouse located\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NY10007 on the\nday of\n20\n.\nP RE S E NT:\nHON.\nJustice\nof the SupremeCourt\nJANEDOE,\nIndex No.:\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nORDERTOSHOWCAUSE\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC., CHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\nUpon reading\nthe Summonsand Complaint\nin\nthis\naction,\ndated September 14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof THOMASP. GIUFFRA, ESQ., of the firm RHEINGOLDGIUFFRA\nRUFFOPLOTKIN& HELLMAN,LLP,\nattorneys\nfor\nPlaintiff,\ndated September\n14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof Plaintiff\nJANEDOEin this\nmatter,\ndated September 14, 2026, and upon\nall\nother papers and proceedings\nheretofore\nannexed herein;\nL E T THEDEFENDANTSAND/ORTHEIR ATTORNEYSAND/OROTHERLEGAL\nREPRESENTATIVES,SHOWCAUSEbefore a Justice\nof this\nCourt,\nat an IAS Part\n, Room\nof this\nCourt,\nto be held\nat the Courthouse\nlocated\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NYon\n\n--- Page 2 ---\nthe\nday of\n, 20___ at\nam/pm or as soon thereafter\nas counsel maybe heard, why an Order cannot be entered\ndirecting,\n1.\nThat the County Clerk enter the caption\nof the above-entitled\nmatter\nin the\ncurrent\nminute books and indices\nof actions\nand maintained\nin\nthe\noffice\nunder the title\nof:\nJANE DOE, Plaintiff,\nv.\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTERHOUSE\nASSOCIATION, CHI PHI FRATERNITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST, ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOF DELTA DELTA DELTA, DELTA DELTA DELTA\nSORORITY, ZAREEN ENTERPRISE LLC\nd/b/a\nMOONIESBAR & NIGHTCLUB,\nMATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHANNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTTKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE BOARD),and ORAZIOPETITO, Defendants.\nORDERED,that\npending\nthe hearing\nof this\nmotion BEFORETHEJUSTICE TO BE\nASSIGNED,the Clerk of this\nCourt,\nupon payment of the proper\nfees,\nbe and is hereby\ndirected\nto\nassign\nan index\nnumber to\nthis\nproceeding,\nand to\naccept\nfor\nfiling\na Request for\nJudicial\nIntervention\n(\"RJI\"),\nbearing\nthe following\ncaption,\nnamely:\nSUPREMECOURTOFTHESTATEOFNEWYORK\nC,OUNTYOFNEWYORK\nJANEDOE,\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC., CHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\n2\n\n--- Page 3 ---\nand it is further\n\nORDERED, service of a copy of this Order to Show Cause together with the papers upon\nAAD TR SumenS Med LOM PLM ve\nwhich it is basedsbe served upon the defendant on or before the day of ,\n20\n\nENTER:\n\nJustice of the Supreme Court\n","text":"--- Page 1 ---\nAt\nof the Supreme Court of\nthe State\nof NewYork County of NewYork,\nheld\nat the Courthouse located\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NY10007 on the\nday of\n20\n.\nP RE S E NT:\nHON.\nJustice\nof the SupremeCourt\nJANEDOE,\nIndex No.:\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nORDERTOSHOWCAUSE\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC., CHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\nUpon reading\nthe Summonsand Complaint\nin\nthis\naction,\ndated September 14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof THOMASP. GIUFFRA, ESQ., of the firm RHEINGOLDGIUFFRA\nRUFFOPLOTKIN& HELLMAN,LLP,\nattorneys\nfor\nPlaintiff,\ndated September\n14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof Plaintiff\nJANEDOEin this\nmatter,\ndated September 14, 2026, and upon\nall\nother papers and proceedings\nheretofore\nannexed herein;\nL E T THEDEFENDANTSAND/ORTHEIR ATTORNEYSAND/OROTHERLEGAL\nREPRESENTATIVES,SHOWCAUSEbefore a Justice\nof this\nCourt,\nat an IAS Part\n, Room\nof this\nCourt,\nto be held\nat the Courthouse\nlocated\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NYon\n\n--- Page 2 ---\nthe\nday of\n, 20___ at\nam/pm or as soon thereafter\nas counsel maybe heard, why an Order cannot be entered\ndirecting,\n1.\nThat the County Clerk enter the caption\nof the above-entitled\nmatter\nin the\ncurrent\nminute books and indices\nof actions\nand maintained\nin\nthe\noffice\nunder the title\nof:\nJANE DOE, Plaintiff,\nv.\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTERHOUSE\nASSOCIATION, CHI PHI FRATERNITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST, ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOF DELTA DELTA DELTA, DELTA DELTA DELTA\nSORORITY, ZAREEN ENTERPRISE LLC\nd/b/a\nMOONIESBAR & NIGHTCLUB,\nMATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHANNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTTKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE BOARD),and ORAZIOPETITO, Defendants.\nORDERED,that\npending\nthe hearing\nof this\nmotion BEFORETHEJUSTICE TO BE\nASSIGNED,the Clerk of this\nCourt,\nupon payment of the proper\nfees,\nbe and is hereby\ndirected\nto\nassign\nan index\nnumber to\nthis\nproceeding,\nand to\naccept\nfor\nfiling\na Request for\nJudicial\nIntervention\n(\"RJI\"),\nbearing\nthe following\ncaption,\nnamely:\nSUPREMECOURTOFTHESTATEOFNEWYORK\nC,OUNTYOFNEWYORK\nJANEDOE,\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC., CHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\n2\n\n--- Page 3 ---\nand it is further\n\nORDERED, service of a copy of this Order to Show Cause together with the papers upon\nAAD TR SumenS Med LOM PLM ve\nwhich it is basedsbe served upon the defendant on or before the day of ,\n20\n\nENTER:\n\nJustice of the Supreme Court\n","thumbnailUrl":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/thumb.webp","transcriptStatus":"not_applicable","transcriptText":"","url":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357"}